A single girder vs double girder crane remote control is not a choice between two radios. It is the same radio matched to two different machines. On a single girder the hoist is the trolley, running under one beam with three motions. On a double girder the trolley is a separate frame riding on top of two beams and usually carrying two hoists, so the receiver needs twice the outputs, a second panel and its own anti-collision logic. Count motions before you count buttons.

Single Girder: The Hoist Is the Trolley

The trolley wheels run on the bottom flange of a single I-beam or box girder, and the hoist hangs from that frame rather than sitting on top of it. Hoist, cross travel and long travel are therefore the complete motion list, and there is nothing else for the operator to command.

Electrically that is one contactor panel, usually at the end of the girder or on the trolley, holding the reversing contactors for all three motions. A retrofit receiver sits beside it, takes its control voltage from it, and its output relays close the same coils the pendant buttons used to close. Six outputs cover three motions with spares for a horn and a start relay.

Panel and receiver normally end up within a couple of metres of each other, so the control cable is short and the antenna can be kept clear of the motor housings. That is why adding radio control to an existing crane of this type is usually a one-day job.

Single girder crane with a hoist trolley running under one I-beam, controlled by a radio remote control transmitter

Double Girder: The Trolley Carries the Hoists

On a double girder crane the trolley is a rectangular frame with four wheels running on rails on top of both girders, and the hoist is bolted onto that frame instead of being the frame. That is the structure that lets a main and an auxiliary hoist share one trolley, and it changes the control count immediately.

Two hoists mean four hoist directions instead of two: main up, main down, auxiliary up, auxiliary down. Add cross travel and long travel and the machine needs eight outputs before a horn, a start relay or a hoist selector. A six-button handset cannot express that and an eight-relay receiver cannot drive it.

Where the hardware lives changes as well. Panels are often split between the trolley, the bridge and the auxiliary hoist, so cable runs are longer and the receiver must sit where the cable does not flex itself to death.

Limit Switches and Collision Logic on a Double Girder

Limit switches belong to the machine, not to the radio, and that does not change between crane types. What changes is how many of them the operator works against at once, and how the receiver must behave when one trips.

A hoist upper limit normally cuts the coil of the up contactor. If the receiver is still holding its up relay closed at that moment, nothing dangerous happens, because the limit breaks the circuit downstream of the relay. The dangerous version is a maintained output: the relay stays closed after the hand leaves the button, so when the limit resets the hoist starts again on its own. With one hoist that is a nuisance. With two it is a hazard, because the second hoist may still be moving while the first one re-energises.

A double girder also creates a collision problem that a single girder does not have in the same form. Both hoists share the same cross-travel rails and can be driven into each other. The receiver has no idea where the other hoist is, so the interlock has to come from the crane: a mechanical stop with a limit switch, a proximity sensor pair wired into both hoist circuits, or an anti-collision unit that cuts the approach direction. The radio’s only job is to stop repeating a command that has been overruled. If the enquiry never says the crane has two hoists, nobody will quote the interlock.

Two Hoists, One Transmitter: Three Arrangements

There is more than one way to drive two hoists from one handset, and the right answer depends on how often the auxiliary hoist is actually used.

ArrangementHardwareHow the operator switchesBest for
One receiver, extended relay set10 to 12 outputs, all functions on the panelDedicated buttons, always liveBoth hoists used in quick succession
Two receivers, one transmitterOne receiver per hoist panel, both paired to one handsetRotary or key selector chooses the active hoistAuxiliary used occasionally, panels far apart
Two transmitters, one machineTwo handsets, transfer by key or explicit handoverOperators hand over controlLong cycles where the driver walks the bay

The first arrangement is what most double girder buyers end up with, and it matches a crane remote control system built around 10 to 12 functions. The second is common on older machines whose two panels were never designed to talk to each other. The third is a working practice rather than a product, covered in two transmitters for one crane. None of the three is interchangeable at the wiring level, so choose the arrangement before the receiver is ordered.

Double girder crane trolley carrying a main and an auxiliary hoist above two girders in a workshop bay

Counting the Functions Before You Order

Function count decides which receiver and which transmitter you need. Count motions and directions separately, because every direction is one relay and one wire.

MachineMotionsOutputsReceiver
Single girder, one hoistHoist, cross travel, long travel68-output
Single girder, two-speed hoistHoist in two speeds plus travel7 to 88-output
Double girder, main hoist onlyHoist, cross travel, long travel68-output
Double girder, main and auxiliaryTwo hoists plus both travels10 to 1212-output or dual receiver
Double girder, two trolleys or rotating trolleyAs above plus rotation12 or moreDual receiver, shared handset

A two-speed hoist adds one function per speed and is normally done with a changeover rather than a second full motion. Button count is a layout question, not a functional one: a 12-function machine fits an 8-button handset with a selector, and a 6-function machine is often bought with 8 buttons because the spare pair drives a horn and a work light. The crane remote control quote checklist settles the layout in six questions, and the ten-function wireless remote control is the model most double girder retrofits land on.

What Changes in a Retrofit

The sequence is the same on both crane types, but a double girder adds two steps that catch people out. Work through it in this order.

  1. Photograph the existing pendant or cab panel and list every function. The panel in front of you is the truth; machines get modified over their working life.
  2. Count contactor coils, not buttons. If two buttons drive one coil through a changeover, that is one relay, not two.
  3. Measure the control voltage at the coil terminals. Coils are commonly 24 to 380 V AC or 12 and 24 V DC, and the receiver is ordered to match. Guessing this is the most expensive mistake on the list.
  4. Choose the receiver position for cable life, not convenience. On a double girder that normally means the bridge panel, not the moving trolley.
  5. Decide whether the pendant stays. If both stations stay live, add a selector or key switch so only one is enabled at a time; two live stations on one crane is a hazard, not redundancy.
  6. Confirm the limits still break the coil circuit. The receiver sits upstream of the limit switches, never across them.
  7. Test every direction unloaded, then with a load. Check the handset emergency stop, the signal-loss behaviour and, on a double girder, the interlock between the two hoists.

Two further items matter on a double girder: the second hoist panel usually needs its own fused supply for the receiver, and the antenna must sit clear of the trolley motors and the festoon system. A receiver that behaves perfectly on a single girder can behave badly on a double girder because the antenna ended up inside the steel box formed by the two girders. The conventions are set out in crane remote control wiring diagram. If you would rather have the function list checked before ordering, send the panel photos through the contact form and we will map them to a receiver.

FAQ

Can one remote control work on both crane types?

The transmitter usually can, if it has enough buttons and the right frequency band. The receiver cannot, because the two machines need different output counts and, on a double girder, different interlock logic.

How many buttons does a double girder remote need?

Ten is the practical minimum for a main and auxiliary hoist with both travels, plus a horn. Twelve is common once a start relay, work light or hoist selector is added. A double girder with a single hoist needs the same six as a single girder.

Does a double girder need two receivers?

Not necessarily, but often in practice. One 12-output receiver is cleaner when both panels sit close together; two receivers are the usual answer when the panels are far apart or the auxiliary hoist has its own control system nobody wants to rewire.

Why does antenna position matter more on a double girder?

Because the two girders, the walkway and the trolley frame form a steel enclosure. An antenna mounted low between the girders can lose line of sight to a driver at the far end of the bay. Mount it high and test from the worst operating position, not from the panel.

Previous Post

Heavy Duty Limit Switch for Crane Travel

Next Post

Precast Concrete Crane Remote Control: Dust, Steam, Weather

Related Posts

+86-18989776059 Phone iehc1@iehcele.com E-mail Chat on WhatsApp WhatsApp